Check out our Past Newsletters here
*|MC:SUBJECT|*
 J U N E   2 0 2 2
All the news from the team at Carolyn Lee PLLC 
UPCOMING EVENTS
EB-5 RIA WEBINAR: STATE OF PLAY
 
Please join us for our RIA webcast discussing Regional Center re-designations, litigation, new forms, and more. Presented by Carolyn Lee on June 22nd at 2:00 PM ET. Register below.
Register

EB-5 State of Play: Remain Seated with Seatbelts Fastened

By Carolyn Lee

I have always said you need a strong stomach for EB-5. Even those blessed with bellies of steel are reaching for their bedside Pepto these past weeks. Stocking up seems the best advice for the near future and here’s why.

Backdrop.

On March 15, 2022, we got nearly 100 pages of new EB-5 law bringing reform and reauthorization after 9 months of lapse in the regional center program. But before the first bottle of champagne emptied and mid-high five, we were dealt floor comments from Congress suggesting that regional centers needed to seek redesignation under the EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act of 2022 (RIA) before operating again. Mais, comment?

IIUSA then dispatched a letter to USCIS with the message, Whatever you do, please do not follow this interpretation; if you absolutely must, please allow redesignation with an attestation-only filing and not a filing requiring your adjudication. Because speed isn’t everyone’s forté. Receiving no response, IIUSA sent a second letter in April emphasizing the same message, hoping no doubt, to head off any USCIS misdirection.

On April 29, 2022, USCIS gave the EB-5 community its answer. It wasn’t the one beseeched. By a web posting entitled EB-5 Questions and Answers, USCIS indicated that regional centers would indeed need to apply for designation and furthermore obtain approval before operating. The USCIS Questions and Answers state: “The EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act of 2022 repealed the legacy Regional Center Program. As a result, previously designated regional centers must reapply by filing the new Form I-956, Application for Regional Center Designation.”

The USCIS Questions and Answers further state that investors must wait until the I-956 is approved, and further an exemplar filed and receipted before filing their associated I-526 petitions: “Individuals seeking status as an immigrant investor whose investment project is associated with a regional center (with an approved Form I-956 after May 14, 2022), may file a Form I-526, Immigrant Petition by Alien Entrepreneur, only after the regional center has submitted a project application and received a receipt number for that application.” 

The USCIS Listening Session later that day on April 29 made matters worse. As well-intentioned as it was, the Listening Session showed that USCIS is tone-deaf to stakeholder expectations and reasonable alternative interpretations of this massive new body of EB-5 authority. Advocacy point #1 coming – wait for it: USCIS must find a way to engage substantively with EB-5 stakeholders in advance of momentous RIA implementation. This can be done consistently with RIA’s transparency provisions. The alternative is a series of lawsuits.

Speaking of which (or shall I say “Exhibit A”), not taking USCIS’s position sitting down, in April 2022, Behring Regional Center LLC sued USCIS challenging its RIA interpretation as requiring regional center redesignations. In May 2022, IIUSA, CanAm Enterprises, EB5 Capital, Pine State Regional Center, Golden Gate Global, and Civitas Capital filed a second lawsuit against USCIS on similar grounds. Your Honor, “Exhibit B.” Based on the last hearing held June 2, 2022, it appears Judge Chhabria in the Behring case is inclined to rule for the plaintiff. The question is whether the ruling will be limited to favor just the plaintiff, Behring, or cover similarly situated regional centers more broadly. IIUSA has astutely intervened to request a broader remedy covering all similarly situated regional centers.

What could happen from here?

The Behring court could rule that USCIS needs to go back and formulate reasoning for its RIA interpretation and rule in the plaintiff’s favor. What would be the impact?

If the remedy favors Behring alone, then Behring will enjoy a windfall until either IIUSA members’ lawsuit wins broader remedy or USCIS backs up its original RIA interpretation with more analysis, whichever happens first.
If the remedy favors regional centers more broadly, then all the pre-RIA regional centers are back in business. In that scenario, the regional centers must simply file a business plan with the new Form I-956F and its new EB-5 investors can file as soon as USCIS issues a receipt.

What then? Impact on investors?

It’s all about two big gifts from RIA. First, the set-asides.
The State Department’s position is that the set-asides are for post-RIA investors only. This means that a window will open for new Chinese investors with “current” visa availability in the 32% set aside categories (Rural, High Unemployment, Infrastructure) although still backlogged in the “5th Unreserved” category. See the July 2022 Visa Bulletin:
       

Importantly, we have nearly double the normal EB-5 numbers this fiscal year due to unused family numbers spilling over. This is much the same “spillover” phenomenon as experienced last year. The effect is that rather than merely about 3,200 set aside EB-5 visas, we have about 6,400. Moreover, unused set aside numbers will roll over to the next fiscal year and be added to the FY 2023 annual reserve. That means in FY 2023, we could have a maximum of over 9,000 visas in the set aside categories, almost what we normally have in all of EB-5 annually. Wow.

We must face the hard fact that many of these wonderful numbers will go unused if USCIS I-526 processing times continue to lag. We’d need rapid and sound adjudication of I-526s in FY 2022 to allow these abundant FY 2023 numbers to be allocated. So Advocacy point #2: Even if processing times across the board cannot be ameliorated, USCIS must give effect to prioritizing “current” cases per its own “visa availability approach.”
Accompanying Advocacy point #3: figure out a way to classify at least pending I-526 petitions with the new set aside categories; if possible, reclassify the approved I-526 petitions with the new set aside categories also. Doing so will allow the optimum number of backlogged investors who filed pre-RIA to benefit from the set asides.

Second, it’s about concurrent Adjustments of Status (AOS) applications.

Let’s start here with Advocacy point #4: we need to figure out a way to allow EB-5 investors abroad to enter the U.S. to file concurrent adjustments of status. The State Department, we are told, is still struggling to recover from Covid. And the world’s conflicts have not helped as we extend our humanitarian helping hand through our diplomatic missions. USCIS is better equipped to scale, we are told.

If this is true, here comes the closer – Advocacy point #5: we must support and at the same time press DHS and USCIS to expediently adjudicate Forms I-485, Adjustment of Status (AOS) applications. Concurrent filings are wonderful and a reason to celebrate RIA’s arrival. But unless the I-485s are approved, we are letting precious visa numbers go unused. With consulates’ meagre EB-5 visa issuances particularly in Guangzhou, we must all do all we can to allow eligible AOS applications to be efficiently approved. Doing so will optimize the EB-5 visas windfall in FY 2022 and FY 2023, giving everyone a good reason to empty that first champagne bottle with gusto and indeed, crack open the second.

It'll be turbulent in the meantime and our little sky window may not reveal exactly where we’re going. But I’m looking forward to the warmth and sunshine where we land.
 
RECENT EVENTS

Carolyn Lee Led IIUSA's Informational Webinar on the Form I-956 - Regional Center Designation

Carolyn moderated a discussion of the fast-evolving context of Regional Center re-designations, particularly in light of recent litigation against USCIS. We focused on practical questions and tips for completing the Form I-956 and I-956H.
 
With the announcement of the new Form I-956F, Application for Approval of an Investment in a Commercial Enterprise  (formerly called an “exemplar” application) and the new Form I-956G, Regional Center Annual Statement (formerly the Form I-924A), we touched on these important forms as well and what RIA says about them.
 

 

Carolyn was the Chairperson of an AILA Virtual EB-5 8-week Online Course offered throughout May in which RIA was analyzed in-depth by the industries leading experts. See the recording here.
GOVERNMENT NEWS

New RIA Forms I-956 and I-956G

On June 2, 2022, USCIS released the following message about the new I-956 Forms:

Form I-956F is a new form that can only be filed by an approved regional center. Form I-956F is similar in some respects to an “exemplar” submission on Form I-924 under the previous program; however, Form I-956F is required by statute for regional centers to apply for approval of each particular investment offering through an associated new commercial enterprise.

Form I-956G takes the place of Form I-924A from the previous program but incorporates the increased statutory reporting requirements.

The next series of forms USCIS will be releasing are Form I-526, Immigrant Petition by Standalone Investor, and Form I-526E, Immigrant Petition by Regional Center Investor. USCIS will notify stakeholders once these forms are available on our website.
 

We are pleased to put our knowledge of RIA, new indirect job creation requirements, and industry standard-setting exemplar experience to work for EB-5 Projects. Contact us for your Form I-956F Filing.
 

CONTACT US
I-526 Processing Times
China-Mainland



See Processing Times>>
I-526 Processing Times
All Other Areas



See Processing Times>>
I-829 Processing Times


See Processing Times>>
 
EB-5 OBSERVATIONS
JULY 2022 VISA BULLETIN
  • China Mainland-born Final Action Date (FAD) and Dates for Filing (DFF) are both still current in all the set-aside categories - Rural Area (RA), High Unemployment Area (HUA), and Infrastructure (IA).
  • Rest of world (ROW) is current across the board, meaning all investors except mainland-born Chinese investors may concurrently file their Adjustment of Status (AOS) applications if eligible.
  • China Mainland-born investors in non-set aside categories (now called 5th Unreserved including DIRECT EB-5) has a FAD of 22NOV2015.
  • China Mainland-born investors in non-set aside categories (now called 5th Unreserved including DIRECT EB-5) has a DFF of 22DEC2015.
Note: USCIS has announced that for July 2022, AOS applicants must use Final Action Dates in the July 2022 Visa Bulletin. USCIS will announce when it will use the Dates for Filing for AOS applications.
 
July 2022 VB
Please visit our previous post for information about the
Visa Bulletin and a listing of terms and definitions.

Connecting with CLP

We are proud to be a trusted resource in these dynamic times for
U.S. Investment Immigration.

CONTACT US
Facebook
LinkedIn
Twitter
Website
Email
Copyright © 2022 Carolyn Lee PLLC, All rights reserved.


Our mailing address is:
Carolyn Lee PLLC
PO Box 8
Ithaca, NY 14851-0008
Add us to your address book